Sign up for our newsletter and get a curated list of the top trending stories and exclusive rewards every day.

Trending Topics

Get the MTL Blog app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The NYC vs. MTL Bagel Wars Have Reignited On Twitter & It's Getting Messy, Guys

Bagel Wars, Episode VII: Are all bagels equally good?
Senior Editor
The NYC vs. MTL Bagel Wars Have Reignited On Twitter

It's the return of the bagel wars. The longstanding Twitter debate — in which New Yorkers, Montrealers and sometimes New Jerseyans (???) fight over their local recipes for bread with a hole in the middle — has reignited. 

And Montrealers aren't going down without a fight.

Editor's Choice: 12 Unusual Things Montreal Does Differently Than Everywhere Else

How did the bagel debate start this time?

This time, in addition to their usual New York counterparts, Quebec bagel lovers are facing off with Californians and what looks like a growing neutral faction arguing that the debate is silly and that bagels all basically taste the same.

The current debate follows the publication of an article titled "The Best Bagels Are in California (Sorry, New York)" in The New York Times.

In it, restaurant critic Tejal Rao highlights what she calls a "bagel boom" in California, which, according to her reporting, includes Montreal and New York-style bagels.

(MTL Blog has reached out to Rao for a comment on this story and the ongoing Twitter debate. This article will be updated when we get a response.)

What are the bagel factions saying?

Well, exactly what you'd expect. Though this time they're mostly keeping it civil — save for a few expletives.

Among Montreal bagel lovers, there's also the usual splintering of the conversation into arguments about Fairmount and Saint-Viateur bagels.

Interestingly, in some cases, it looks like Montrealers and New Yorkers have stopped targeting each other and are instead saving their strongest feelings for California. Could this be the beginning of a new alliance?

Then there are the few, very persistent, New Jersey bagel enthusiasts. They're backed by the official Twitter account of the government of the state of New Jersey.

Is this bagel debate pointless?

That's what some people seem to think.

In at least a few highly-circulated tweets, neutral parties are arguing that all bagels are kind of the same.

Others, like Canadian comedian Jay Baruchel, are taking issue with this line of thinking.

[rebelmouse-image 26879851 photo_credit="BaruchelNDG | Twitter" expand=1 original_size="589x277"] BaruchelNDG | Twitter

It seems the bagel alliances are shifting. Could this work out in Montreal's favour?

More from MTL Blog

Comments 💬

Our comment section is a place to promote self-expression, freedom of speech and positivity. We encourage discussion and debate, but our pages must remain a safe space where everyone feels comfortable and the environment is respectful.

In order to make this possible, we monitor comments to keep spam, hate speech, violence, and vulgarity off our pages. Comments are moderated according to our Community Guidelines.

Please note that Narcity Media does not endorse the opinions expressed in the comment section of an article. Narcity Media has the right to remove comments, ban or suspend any user without notice, or close a story’s comment section at any time.

First and last names will appear with each comment and the use of pseudonyms is prohibited. By commenting, you acknowledge that Narcity Media has the right to use & distribute your content across our properties.