Thankfully, you have this article open on your phone. Take a look and find only red wines rated above 4.0 by more than 50 reviewers, at a value not exceeding $20 and not lower than $17. Plus, they're all available to order online, so really you could have skipped this entire in-person ordeal. With pairing notes from the SAQ under each bottle, you'll be able to suggest a meal your girlfriend could start prepping while you take forever to choose your booze.
So take a deep breath, centre yourself and let's get into the wines.
Tom Gore Cabernet-Sauvignon

Tom Gore red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.95
Rating: 4.2/5
Pairing Notes: This wine features a "tannic structure rounded off by ripeness of the sunshine-filled fruit, which fans of full-bodied wines will love." With a cabernet sauvignon like this, rich red meat is a wise pairing, or portobello mushrooms.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Faustino V Rioja Reserva 2017

Faustino V red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.60
Rating: 4.3/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ calls this wine, "A Tempranillo of cherries, strawberries and licorice you’ll want to drink with a beef Wellington filet or pork empanadas." Riojas like this one are best-suited to foods that are spicier and meaty, like a chorizo or lamb tapas.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
19 Crimes Cabernet-Sauvignon Limestone Coast

19 Crimes red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.55
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: This cabernet sauvignon would hold up well paired with a hamburger or another simple, fatty and meaty meal.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Otazu Premium Cuvée Navarra 2019

Otazu red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.50
Rating: 4.6/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with rack of lamb, grilled lamb chops or Texas barbecue beef ribs.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
19 Crimes Shiraz/Grenache/Mataro

19 Crimes red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.55
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with rabbit, filet mignon or French lamb stew. A grenache shiraz mataro blend like this would go nicely with something smokier.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Château Mourgues Du Grès Costières de Nîmes Les Galets 2022

Chateau Mourgues du Gres red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.45
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with spicy pork burgers, Mexican-style chicken, or rabbit rillettes (an interesting and perhaps confusing range of dishes). The somewhat more reliable wine resource behind this bottle recommends pairing this wine with poultry or veal.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Christophe Pacalet Beaujolais les Marcellins 2021

Christophe Pacalet red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.10
Rating: 4.2/5
Pairing Notes: The pairing notes for this wine suggest that it "be served chilled alongside a beef tartare or veal parmigiana cutlet." This type of bottle would also go well with French-style charcuterie, patés and rillettes.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Errazuriz Max Reserva Cabernet-Sauvignon Valle de Aconcagua

Errazuriz Max red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.25
Rating: 4.3/5
Pairing Notes: "Nicely balanced and displaying melted tannins, you’ll love it with braised lamb shanks or beef with mushroom sauce," the wine's SAQ entry reads. As a cabernet sauvignon, it's also a bolder wine, so it needs something hearty to stand up to its flavours.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Cousino-Macul Antiguas Reservas Valle del Maipo

Cousino-Macul red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.00
Rating: 4.3/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with moussaka, braised lamb shanks or grilled beef tenderloin. Another cab sauv, so you know the drill — hearty, meaty and even a little spice will take this wine a long way.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Slow Press Cabernet-Sauvignon

Slow Press red wine.
SAQ
Price: $19.00
Rating: 4.2/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with flank steak, grilled lamb chops or beef tenderloin with chimichurri sauce. Because guess why? It's a cabernet sauvignon. Good job.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Carnivor Cabernet-Sauvignon

Carnivor red wine.
SAQ
Price: $18.75
Rating: 4.3/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with sesame beef skewers, honey-soy glazed pork or veal ribs with mushrooms. But it'll go well with any other hearty, red meat dish. Because it's (say it with me) a cabernet sauvignon.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Luigi Righetti Campolieti Valpolicella Ripasso

Luigi Righetti red wine.
SAQ
Price: $18.75
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with a roast turkey, poutine with pulled duck confit, or smoked meat poutine. It's a red blend, so it's not particularly well-suited to any profile of food beyond the specs of any other average red wine, so think meaty, think heavy, and think spicy.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Sella & Mosca Cannonau di Sardegna Riserva

Sella & Mosca red wine.
SAQ
Price: $18.65
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with filet mignon in peppercorn sauce, lamb burgers with cheddar or cinnamon-and-spice-rub steak. This wine is similar to a grenache, meaning it is dry and full-bodied, going well with mature cheese and white meat.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Carpineto Dogajolo Toscana 2020

Carpineto Dogajolo red wine.
SAQ
Price: $17.95
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with beef bourguignon, grilled beef tenderloin with blue cheese sauce or elk ossu busco. Aromatic and "supple," it would fit nicely alongside cured meats or lamb as well.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Umberto Cesari Moma Rubicone

Umberto Cesari red wine.
SAQ
Price: $17.90
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with bison steak, spareribs or lamb kebabs. The brand itself recommends "first courses of meat, cured pork cuts and roasts."
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Gran Passione Veneto 2020

Gran Passione red wine.
SAQ
Price: $17.70
Rating: 4.2/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with duck à l'orange, sausage calzones or beef tartare. A merlot and corvina blend, this wine would be nice with a red pasta sauce, bruschetta and antipasti.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Château Puyfromage Francs Côtes de Bordeaux

Château Puyfromage red wine.
SAQ
Price: $17.70
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with chicken brochettes and tapenade, venison red wine stew or a steak sandwich with mushrooms. It would also go well with steak and barbecue with its strong, rich flavours.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Labouré-Roi La Princesse Maudite Côteaux Bourguignons

Labouré-Roi red wine.
SAQ
Price: $17.55
Rating: 4.4/5
Pairing Notes: The SAQ recommends pairing this wine with grilled bass and tomato tapenade, grilled chicken gyros or grilled Greek salad. Good with white meat as much as red, this wine is versatile and tasty.
Find this bottle online at the SAQ here
Hopefully, this list can bring you some comfort in times of darkness, when someone requests a good but inexpensive red wine despite your obvious lack of wine tasting skills and social anxiety about asking for help in an SAQ. Listen, we've mostly all been there. I got you.
This article's cover image was used for illustrative purposes only.